Alex,
Since you are already trying different balls on the course (hopefully all Titleist), I would say that which ever one performs the best for all parts of your game (Driving, Putting, Short Game, etc...) is the one you should stick with.

There is a ball fitting available .The tab just below Golf balls on the right side of this page. My 2cents is The DT Trusoft.

Thanks for the replies chaps, I've used both ProV models and both NXT models extensively. However, I asked the question as I've just used Velocity for one and a half rounds and the difference has been startling. I shot 82 yesterday, mainly capitalising on long, straight drives. I may try the TruSoft but I can't see it getting much better than this!
Would still like to hear other people's thoughts...

Alex,
I think it really depends on what you're looking for in a ball. Are you looking to maximize distance and reduce spin? Are you looking for a softer feeling and higher spinning ball? Somewhere in the middle? If you're looking for greenside spin and stopping power, the Pro V line would fit the bill. If you're looking for extra distance and reduced driver spin the Velocity would be the choice. Somewhere in the middle? Give the NXT a spin. Best of luck!

Alex,

With a 19 handicap and a 91 MPH driver club speed the best ball for you is to use the least expensive ball you can afford. An expensive golf ball will not help your game as much as golf lessons will. When you can play consistently at 80 and lower for 18 holes then you can start looking at higher performance golf balls IMHO. Save yourself some money.

DV

Thanks for the replies chaps, I've used both ProV models and both NXT models extensively. However, I asked the question as I've just used Velocity for one and a half rounds and the difference has been startling. I shot 82 yesterday, mainly capitalising on long, straight drives. I may try the TruSoft but I can't see it getting much better than this!
Would still like to hear other people's thoughts...

Most of these guys will tell you to play the ProV1, but with a "bad slice" sneaking in from time to time, that will get expensive quickly.

Since you are a high-ball hitter with plenty of distance on hand, I would go with the TruSoft initially, and maybe move up to the NXT Tour S if you'd like a firmer feel and a little more spin around the greens (chip shots).

Once you get that slice straightened out, do move up to the ProV1 or ProV1x.

Thanks guys, any more thoughts anyone?

Thanks for the replies again, very interesting!

Jaymo37 - yes, I think it probably was less driver spin that I was mainly looking for. Early days, but the Velocity seems to have helped.

DV - I'm not sure what the 'least expensive ball I can afford' is (Used, Grade B Black Diamond? ;0) ) but, given that my bad slice has been such a handicap, I think the better advice has been to go for low-spinning ball.

More thoughts very appreciated!

Alex,

If a very good amatuer or a tour pro played a round of golf with a good condition range ball they would still break par. There is a lot of performance even with lower end golf balls. It would be in anyone's interest to take this into consideration when purchasing a golf ball. I just can't see golfers spending 4 dollars (USD) for a golf ball thinking this is going to get their game into the 70s when all it does is cost the golfer a lot more money to enjoy this game. The average golfer, according to published sources, loses 3 balls a round. Ouch...that can get real expensesive real quick if you are playing ProV. Save yourself some money, your wallet will thank you. You do not need the performance of a high end ball at this stage in your golf game (ie, 80). You might gain a few extra yards from the tee, but your golf scores will not change significantly nor will a golf ball impact your handicap index until your level of play improves.

Best Wishes,

DV

Paly the ball that provides you with the best feel. For me this feel is most important the closer I am to the hole. ProV1x is lower spinning off the driver, yet still has spin for short game shots, and feels soft on the putter face

Hey Alex, we are similiar in age and handicap

I defintely find the Velocity, DT Tru Soft and NXT Tour to be my balls of choice.

I do play the PRO V1 when i am traveling as i have a bunch customized.

The pro v1 is find is incredible around the greens for me. lots of spin and a great feel.

i do get much further off the tee with the Velocity. My next test will be with the PRO v1x to see how it performs

Hughie - 18 handicap, 45 years old

I suggest that you continue using the Velocity on a consistent basis until your handicap is at least 14. At that time, you should try the ProV1's and the NXT's. Play each of them for several rounds and compare your distances, scoring opportunities, and control around the greens. It is possible that the Velocity may continue to be the best ball for you. Good luck with your journey.

Thanks DV, Tom & Hughie for the comments, really appreciate them. The Velocity seem to have helped the most with lessening slices so I will stick with them for the time being (could all be in my head, but I'm happy either way!). I have noticed a difference with ball firmness around the green, but even that's been an advantage so far as I've often seemed to come up short too often with bump'n'runs and putts. Most are now reaching the hole!